40 Ingredients Forever

40 Ingredients Forever

Share this post

40 Ingredients Forever
40 Ingredients Forever
Remember pudding?
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Remember pudding?

Sam Seneviratne's coffee banana pudding

Ali Slagle
Mar 28, 2024
∙ Paid
27

Share this post

40 Ingredients Forever
40 Ingredients Forever
Remember pudding?
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1
Share

Sam Seneviratne is one of my favorite people to watch cook. She makes a huge mess, sings, dances. Her recipe printout is on the floor and her phone, balanced atop a pasta box, has a smudge of avocado on it. And then she swirls around and presents the perfect croissant she made.

Subscribe to 40 Ingredients Forever not for croissants but for weeknight recipes, including one dessert a month.

She is an expert baker, but it’s the carefree way she gets to that miraculous baked good that makes me want in. If you ask her how to bake well, she’ll say “trust your body,” which sounds more fun than culinary school.

I love (and miss!) being on set with Sam—she did half the food styling on my cookbook, and I did the prop styling on her latest two books. Bake Smart came out last year and is worth the price just for the chewy chocolate chip cookie recipe.

But today we’re talking about pudding, a dessert that’s easy to forget and easier to love. It is really shocking how delicious this coffee pudding of Sam’s is. You could just make the pudding and eat it warm, yum, or keep going for a layered dessert that’s special but so basic to make. But then again, it’s Sam, so why am I surprised?

From Sam:

Sometimes I forget how lovely it is to whip up a pudding. No special equipment. No worrying about the temperature of anything. No laminating. I’m all for a project bake, but when you need something quick and sweet and endlessly satisfying, pudding is your pal. This one is made with instant espresso powder, which is one of my favorite baking pantry essentials: It lasts forever and adds a big coffee punch to desserts. Instant coffee would work too, but you’ll want to double (or maybe even triple) the amount. You can always taste and adjust to your liking. You could even steep the milk with some regular ground coffee but that will take longer.

I gussied this one up with some bananas and whipped cream. If you’re feeling extra-fancy, crumble in some cookies or graham crackers and top with some grated bittersweet chocolate.

Follow Sam on Instagram

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Ali Slagle
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More